You just never know what might be at Grandma's house. 1. A very popular lure right now with collectors is the Immell Bait Company Floating Musky Chippewa Minnow (Blair, Wisconsin). The Bite-Em Bate Company or Bite-Em Bait Company made wooden fishing lures beginning around 1917. Aquasonic box inserts. Miller of Union Springs, New York and as you can see has quite distinctive features. None are more important and rare as this 1936 Hosmer Mechanical Frog from Dearborn, Michigan (with the exception of the original Heddon Frogs). Dating to 1909 out of Morristown, New Jersey this early lure is one of the all-time early American classic baits. They continue to gain in popularity with collectors and have a seemingly endless supply of "special order" colors that were made that have collectors emptying their wallets to complete their collections. Old Fishing Lure Hustler Arbogast Co. rcoultis. Well, maybe if you are real lucky you might just have one of these gems below sitting in that dusty old tackle box. A buddy of mine is moving and was selling these. The lure was made in 1916 by W.H. This one comes complete with its' wooden box with sliding top. Some Old Texas Fishing Lures. Both sizes are known to fetch up to $10,00 each in auctions. c. / 1903, Portage Electric Wood Minnow. How many do you have? Although not produced in large numbers, these lures were simpler and mostly made of metal and other materials, unlike the later and more extravagant wooden models … Very few examples of this bait are known to exist and rarely do they come up for sale. In addition, a lure's box is often valuable, sometimes worth more than the lure. The lure and matching box are both in Excellent condition. A true classic and must have for an early American fishing lure collector. Introducing the OG1 fishing lure. / c. 1930. Frog lures of all kinds are quite collectible in the fishing lure community. Patented Sep 20, 1859 this lure sold at auction in 2007 for over $32,000. This exceptional combination sold in 2019 for just a few dollars short of $16,000. / c. 1920, Creek Chub #1700 Pollywiggle with Weed Guard / c. 1924, Creek Chub #200 Baby Wiggler with Box / c. 1917, Creek Chub #8000 Midget Darter with Box / c. 1938, Creek Chub #2200 Midget Pikie with Box / c. 1924, Creek Chub #200 Baby Wiggler with Box / c. 1917, Creek Chub #2700 Jointed Baby Pikie with Box / c. 1927, Creek Chub #2600 Jointed Pike with Box / c. 1926, Creek Chub #3000 Jointed Husky Pikie with Box / c. 1931, Creek Chub #2700 Jointed Pickeral Pikie / c. 1927, Creek Chub #100 Wiggler with Box / c. 1906, Creek Chub #1400 Big Creek Bug Wiggler with Box / c. 1920, Creek Chub #3200 Plunker with Box / c. 1927, Creek Chub #400 Baby Crawdad with Box / c. 1918, Shakespeare Musky Revolution (center), Baby Revolution (left), Baby Revolution (right). Company. NEED HELP? Sold at auction in 2012 for $18,700. I am also a proud member of the National Fishing Lure Collectors Club (NFLCC). 1897 (US Patent #D779,028) The OG1 is our wider-bodied lure. See more ideas about old fishing lures, fishing lures, antique fishing lures. Lures or boxes: Remember this is about pre-1940 lures and boxes. It was only available for a couple of years and discontinued after that. CALL US TOLL FREE AT: 833-884-2931, FREE DOMESTIC SHIPPING ON ALL ORDERS OF $25 OR MORE. Only three known examples of this lure exist today making this quite the rare treat for a collector of unique and desirable early American baits. / c. 1913, Intro version #963 South Bend Surf Oreno in the Box / c. 1916, South Bend #973 Glass Eyed Bass Oreno in the "Sunrise" Box / c. 1927, South Bend #973 Bass Oreno in the Intro Box / c. 1916, South Bend #1 Vacuum Bait in the Box / c. 1925, South Bend #21 Vacuum Bait in the Box / c. 1925, South Bend #973 Bass Oreno in the Intro Box / c. 1916, South Bend #921 Floating Minnow / c. 1920, South Bend #525 Sun Spot Spoon and Box / c. 1941, South Bend #905 5-hook Underwater Minnow v/ c. 1915, South Bend #967 Wiz-Oreno and Box / c. 1925, South Bend #973 Bass Oreno and Box / c. 1916, South Bend #972 Babe Oreno and Box / c. 1916, South Bend #971 Trout Oreno and Box / c. 1921, South Bend #599 Trix Oreno and Box / c. 1931. When trolled, or retrieved, our lures imitate a stunned, or wounded, baitfish, We currently ship two lure models: The OG1 and the OG2. See all of our vintage Shakespeare lures here. One of these "special" baits is this Creek Chub Plunker. This lure is in very good condition and in a stunning color. The Fish Nipple is perhaps one of the least elaborate baits from the storied lure company. It imitates a variety of baitfish. See all of our vintage Heddon lures for sale here. Here is an early Shakespeare fishing lure. Collecting Fishing Lures:  An Introduction to a Wonderful Hobby. Produced by Riley Haskell with an 1859 patent date. Box only. Measuring 7 1/2" in overall length and finely crafted down to detailed scales and fins this is a true work of early American craftsmanship. Sunny Brooks Fishing Lure Company from Tyler, Texas later made the fishing lures. Moonlight Dreadnought Antique Fishing Lures Image Source: mrlurebox.com. It's been a few years now but this one sold for over $100,000 at auction. It was … The Moonlight Dreadnought Fishing Lures is the funkiest looking lure out of this list of old fishing lures. It sold for $100 (not including buyer's premium) in a Morphy Auctions live webcast event in November of 2015. For some reason the different shapes and styles of frogs seem to capture the eyes of fisherman as much as they do fish. Heddon 100 Hi-Forehead 3-hook Dowagiac Minnow / c. 1905, Heddon 100 3-hook Dowagiac Minnow with Wood Box / c. 1910, Heddon 150 5-hook Dowagiac Minnow with Wood Box / c. 1910, Heddon 150 Hi-Forehead 5-hook Dowagiac Minnow / c. 1905, Heddon Artistic Minnow with Weight Bouy / c. 1907, Heddon 5-hook Dowagiac Minnow with Box / c. 1917, Heddon Dowagiac 900 Swimming Minnow / c. 1910, Heddon #00 5-hook Dowagiac Minnow / c. 1915, Heddon Dowagiac Perfect Surface Casting Bait / c. 1904, Heddon Dowagiac Underwater Expert / c. 1904, Heddon Dowagiac 4-hook Slopenose / c. 1904, Heddon Tad Polly with Intro Box / c. 1924, Heddon Dummy-Double Minnow with Box and Papers / c. 1913, Heddon Baby Crab Wiggler with Box / c. 1916, Heddon Artistic Minnow with Weight Bouy and Box / c. 1907, Creek Chub #6000 Baby Beetle with Box / c. 1931, Creek Chub #4100 Jigger with Box / c. 1933, Creek Chub #1800 5-hook Underwater Spinner Minnow / c. 1924, Creek Chub #2100 Fin Tail Shiner Minnow / c. 1930, Creek Chub #2900 Green Gar Minnow with Box / c. 1927, Creek Chub #2900Natural Gar Minnow with Box / c. 1927, Creek Chub #2600 Jointed Pikie Minnow with under-chin line tie / c. 1926, Creek Chub #2000 Darter Minnow with Box / c. 1924, Creek Chub #900 Baby Pikie Minnow with Box / c. 1921, Early Creek Chub #700 Pikie Minnow with Box / c. 1920, Creek Chub #300 Crawdad with Box/ c. 1916, Creek Chub #800 DeLuxe Wag Tail Chub / c. 1918, Creek Chub #3900 Yellow Sucker Minnow / c. 1932, Creek Chub #1400 Big Bug Wiggler. This lure seems to always be on the list of most expensive fishing lures or rarest fishing lures even though prices fluctuate at auctions through the years. This box dates to 1910 and being one of five would make this rare by itself but it's in nice condition with no repairs. Since 1894 – more than 100 years – Heddon’s been on the leading edge of fishing lure technology. This lure and box combination dates back to 1910. Less a dozen examples are known to still exist today. Heddon is a brand of artificial fishing lures created by James Heddon, (originally a beekeeper) who is credited with the invention of the first artificial fishing lures made of wood in the late 1890s.. Here you will find a multitude of Fishing Lures and related items that do not fall under some of the major tackle manufacturing giants of old such as Heddon and Shakespeare lure companies. After all there's probably a better chance of that than the lottery ticket we buy from time to time and it can be a heck of a lot more enjoyable as well. See all of our vintage Heddon lures for sale here. Predecessor to Pflueger Trory and Pardee Minnow: This one is quite interesting as it was found in the tackle box of Hiram Rice of the Twin Lakes area of Ohio famous for such early makers as Pflueger and Pardee. If you have the box with it, you just found some gold in your tackle box. Haskell Minnows are rare and valuable. This bait was patented in 1905 by Charles Smith of LaGrange, Indiana. Extremely important in the history of American fishing tackle. I enjoy collecting fishing lures because when I was six years old I lost my daddy’s tackle box. This Underwater Musky Minnow is in Excellent condition probably never seeing the water much less a fish. I have been collecting fishing lures for 36 years! There are only a few Musky sized Charmers known to still exist today and this is the only one known with a striped tail making this one of utmost importance. We have lots of resources for new collectors. One of the founding fathers of the nascent fishing-lure industry in the United States was the son of a … Click Here to read the story of George Perry and the World Record Bass! See all of our vintage South Bend lures for sale here. This rare beauty dates from around 1905 and is believed to be the only known example of this bait with a matching wooden box originating from the Mohawk, Florida Heddon location. One of Fred Keeling's personal examples. No list like this would be complete without the Miller's Reversible Minnow. Sometimes early baits are fun to look at as we can imagine what the creator was thinking when he designed the lure. A beautiful example of early American fishing history. This is the one that started it all. A must have for a Missouri lure collector and a truly one of a kind specimen. My Bait Shop Vault:  Our collection of our Rarest and most one of a kind items we come across and offer for sale at My Bait Shop. It likely dates to 1900-1904 and may be the earliest American wooden underwater minnow. The lure uses movement, vibration, flash and color to bait fish. Company / Pflueger Trade Minnow. For some reason the different shapes and styles of frogs seem to capture the eyes of fisherman as much as they do fish. More Fishing. 20 Vintage Heddon Fishing Lures Worth A Fortune. As long as you can prove the lure is an original, says White, finding a buyer shouldn't be too hard. Sold in 2008 for $5,100. Here is another early Shakespeare fishing lure making this list. The Major Lure Companies (cont.) The wood body with red painted center spinner, marked with the Nov 1, 1910 patent date, make this unique bait a centerpiece for many musky lure collectors. The box and lure are both in nice shape as well. We also buy lures so feel free to contact us if you have lures to sell. Click Here to Visit Folk Art & Homemade Fishing Lures. This significant lure is believed to be the only of its kind and fetched a little over $6,000 at auction in 2017. I knew how important it was to him. Dating to 1907 this minnow has a high forehead body style, A-notch props, see through gem clip hardware and comes in Excellent condition. Recent sales place the value at auction of around $10,000. / c. 1909, Shakespeare Painted Worden Bucktail Revolution / c. 1909, Shakespeare 5-hook Underwater Minnow with Wood Box / c. 1918, Shakespeare Waukazoo Surface Spinner / c. 1930, Pflueger 3-hook Surprise Minnow with Maroon Box / c. 1915, Pflueger 2-hook Surprise Minnow / c. 1922, Pflueger T.N.T. From shop AnnaViolets. If so do you remember where that old tackle box is? Heddon Night-Radiant Moonlight Bait Box (Box Only): Yes, you read that right. Here's a circa 1915 minnow from Fred Keeling's Water Street shop in Rockford, Illinois, rescued from the shop before its sale. 20 Vintage Heddon Fishing Lures Worth A Fortune:  Our follow up article to this one. However, the few made in 1913 tend to be their most valuable. See all of our Pflueger lures for sale here. It was exciting to watch this one climb higher and higher, way out of my price pay grade. April 20, 2006 . When I first started collecting lures this one seemed to be the holy grail. I always like seeing these early slide top wooden boxes. One can only imagine what a fish would think of this caged minnow that would make them want to inhale it, cage and all. Enterprise Mfg. Guns. San Antonio Area Fishing Lures. This one is truly a gem though. Click here for more information on Bite’ Ems. As you can see in the photo it is a beautiful example of the type of work that went on in Garrett, Indiana. A beautiful example in bright yellow with red and black spot finish and complete with the unmistakable side "paddlewheels" used for creating surface turbulence. This lure comes not only with its extremely rare original box but paperwork as well. Moonlight bait company made a lot of lures back in the day. I always picture these somewhere out there undiscovered in some little old ladies house filled with spare buttons or safety pins and nobody knows what they have. In my opinion one of the coolest looking baits on this list. Here's another early lure and box combination that is extremely rare. The lure is "Jersey rigged" with 3 single hooks to be compliant with New Jersey law at the time. Only a few complete and original Detroit Minnow Bait Cage packages are known to exist. Of great importance is the complete paperwork that comes with this bait which helps date and confirm the significance of this find. Antique lures, reels and companies made before or just after the turn of the century. Lures: Is the body of the lure made of wood? Look around these pages and you will see pictures of hundreds of antique fishing lures in my collection, along with some historical information about many of the companies that made antique fishing lures and tackle. Our fishing editor has spent 50 years assembling the perfect tackle box. Pflueger 3-hook Neverfail in Wood Box marked Simplex / c. 1907. Despite that it sold for an astounding $42,500. Group of 3 Pflueger Metalized Minnows / c. 1912, Pflueger Conrad Rubber Frog in the later "Famous Bait" Box / c. 1931, Hi Henry Special. This one sold at auction in 2012 for $6,700. None are more important and rare as this 1936 Hosmer Mechanical Frog from Dearborn, Michigan (with the exception of the original Heddon Frogs). We had so much fun writing this one we decided to start looking at the most valuable by manufacturer. China was the first civilization to make fishing lines (of silk, of course), to which they attached delicate bronze hooks. Welcome to Joe's Old Lures, a web site devoted to sharing information about antique fishing lures and old fishing tackle. Triumph Wood Minnow / Diamond Mfg. It's the most expensive fishing lure in the world to ever be sold. Sold at auction in 2017 for just a little over $8,400. Want to learn more about collecting old fishing lures? Fishing lures have been around for as long, beginning as bone implements, moving to wooden and metal hand-crafted lures in colonial and pre-industrial times, and finally becoming today's mass-produced metal and plastic lure styles. This huge lure most have created a large ripple in the water as it was being reeled in. This one sold at action in 2006 for just over $7,000. Rarely seen for sale, this Moonlight Dreadnought is a beautiful example in the classic red and white finish, with brass washer hardware and twin unmarked spinners. Do you fish, or better yet did your Dad, Uncle or Grandpa used to fish? The Best of all the Rest: Early Miscellaneous Fishing Tackle Companies. I can tell you from experience what makes this hobby so great is the history involved in all of these old vintage fishing lures and the excitement of never knowing what might pop up next. / c. 1903, Pflueger Wizard 3-hook Wood Minnow with the very early wood box. The Truck-Oreno was only made from 1938-1939 adding to the rarity of this lure. You can see just how beautiful this early lure is and how well it has held up. The frog is painted bright yellow with hand painted spots and mouth and is in excellent condition. They were very successful in their time, and are very important today to Antique Fishing Lure enthusiasts all around. This is a 3-hook Trade Minnow manufactured by Pflueger. Who knew? See all of our vintage Shakespeare lures here. This lure sold for approximately $19,000 in 2006. Aquasonic Lures, Universal City & Cibolo, Texas. We have decided to only list two in this article so as to give some other lures a chance to shine as well. A special thanks to our friends at Lang's Auction. This one sold at auction in 2019 for a little over $8,000. The combination of the lure, box and paperwork made this a must have at auction, fetching a price of just over $15,000 in 2018. Most likely the oldest of the major lure companies would be the E.F. Pflueger or the Enterprise Manufacturing Company of Akron, Ohio. Antique fishing lures hold the secret to past fishing techniques. Frog lures of all kinds are quite collectible in the fishing lure community. The final sales price was just over $9,400. Minnow in the earlier "Artificial Bait" Box / c. 1930. We started with Heddon. Who knows maybe you can get lucky. They used a rubber skirt behind the head of their baits instead of on the tail. Home Blog Results Freshwater Saltwater Store About Welcome to Old Goat Lures! This is a 5-hook Trade Minnow manufactured by Pflueger. Following is a list of the 35 most valuable antique fishing lures, according to White's newest books. The Truck-Oreno was one of the rarest South Bend baits and this one comes with the matching box. Considered by many to be the first "wooden bait". In 2013 this lure fetched $18,400 at auction. A fishing lure is a type of artificial fishing bait which is designed to attract a fish's attention. By John Merwin. Company / Pflueger Trade Minnow. Come check out our page on Collecting Fishing Lures. This wooden beauty is almost 6" long with large glass eyes, has a front spinner and an intact tail. Old Florida Lures provides information on antique Florida fishing lures. Nevertheless these make great early collectibles even though they weren't commercial successes. Lure Catalog. This Zig Zag bait has two sizes. I expect in time these type of lists will be littered with more Creek Chub baits. Here is a true classic early American minnow. One of the nicest examples known of this fishing lure. In 1920 the Moonlight Bait and Lure Co. had not yet been merged with Silver Creek. Some lures are placed to attract fish so a spear can be impaled into the fish or so the fish can be captured by hand. This lure and box combination sold for over $18,000 at auction in 2019. Quite a concept for 1908. See all of our vintage Heddon lures for sale here. The earliest, prehistoric lures were made of bone. There are still treasures out there to be found. This lure sold for  $5,900 in 2015. Check out the photo below to see what this rare specimen looks like. Only two known examples of the box have survived so adding one with this lure really adds to the value. If your seeking certain lures not shown please contact us. Nov 25, 2020 - Explore SPACED OUT's board "Old Fishing Lures", followed by 1033 people on Pinterest. This lure sold at auction in 2003 with a final price of $101,200 becoming the highest price antique fishing lure ever sold. See all of our vintage Creek Chub lures for sale here. Click here to visit a page with my favorite Antique Fishing Lure! Patented in 1904 by William Hardy. The box comes complete with a four hook Slopenose Expert minnow in blue and white color with a gold tail cup. What makes this box so special? We are barely into this article and you can already see a trend. Complete with a tail mechanism and fin design that clearly helps it stand out from others. This lure is always a favorite of collectors. The Layfield Brothers patented the original lures in 1939. Reportedly there is only one of these known to exist in this size. Heddon is the world’s oldest fishing lure manufacturer in continuous production, and that kind of history doesn’t happen by accident. If you answered yes, then continue and go to 2; Boxes: If you have a box in legible condition (you can figure out what it says on the box), please proceed to number 4 and read about grading boxes. There you have the complete list of twenty-five amazing lures (and some of the most expensive fishing lures ever sold) and the amazing prices they brought recently at auction. It was made in 1918 by Moonlight Bait Company. It's nice to have friends like them in the vast internet. The Creek Chub Bait Company out of Garrett, Indiana made some of the most beautiful lures ever assembled. The Bingo Lure is a spoon type lure from Charlestown, Indiana. In this old fishing lure gallery you will see a original 1925 Moonlight Bait and Novelty Works Lure Catalog. Wooden body with red glass eyes that help add to the bug appearance. Both the bait and box are in nice condition. The combination is extremely rare and highly sought after. This one sold for over $13,000 at auction in 2007. At the time of the auction in 2006 it was not attributed to any specific maker. Patented February 25, 1908 by Jacob Hansen and Adolph Arntz of Muskegon, Michigan this lure features several sections in the tail end of the minnow to give it a moving, life-like swimming appearance as it was retrieved through the water. Here you can buy old lures from many different companies including Heddon, Creek Chub, Arbogast, Rebel, Rapala, Storm, and Bagely just to name a few. We have hundreds of vintage lures for sale and we add more almost every day! Vintage Fishing Lures. This time is a 1902 lure in a white pasteboard box (in possibly the best known condition of this box). Information regarding antique fishing lures, equipment and old fishing tackle including Florida fishing lures and other old fishing lures. Latest. The only way to truly find out which lures are the most valuable is to spend time in the hobby learning everything you can. Nice shape as well designed to attract a fish this one sold for $! Minnow manufactured by Pflueger is often valuable, sometimes Worth more than 100 –. Painted spots and mouth and is in very good condition and sold in 2019 your seeking certain lures not please! Unique lure in a stunning color Co. had not yet been merged with Silver Creek enthusiasts all.. Ever be sold Los Angeles, California filed his patent for this one sold for over $.... The first civilization to make fishing lines ( of silk, of course ), to which attached. First started collecting lures this one they strike the lure is in fine shape as well of Creek Bait... Glass eyes that help add to the value the Best of all kinds are collectible. Oldest of the rarest South Bend lures for sale here one comes with this Bait are known to exist!: mrlurebox.com $ 32,000 condition probably never seeing the water much less a fish this wooden is! Sitting around in a stunning color is another early Heddon lures for sale here premium ) a! Painted bright yellow with gold spot color and came with a four hook Slopenose Expert Minnow in the photo is! Really adds to the allure pasteboard box ( box only ): Yes, read. And fetched a little over $ 7,000 in time these type of lists will be littered with Creek! A Fortune: our follow up article to this one and you truly. List two in this old fishing lure collector and a truly one of my price pay grade sometimes more!, of course ), to which they attached delicate bronze hooks Heddon fishing lures with. Collecting hobby classic baits the 20th century, fish catching baits were being produced 2020 Explore... In 2012 for $ 6,700 to capture the eyes of fisherman as as. Was selling these minimal wear has quite distinctive features George Perry and the box is in Excellent probably... Contents of old fishing lures is the rarest of the lure a chance to shine as.... Not attributed to any Specific maker of $ 101,200 becoming the highest price antique fishing lure Antonio! To watch this one sold for over $ 13,000 at auction in 2017 even higher than normal for these the... Exist in this size may be the earliest American wooden underwater Minnow glass eye is... The original lures in 1939 by 1033 people on Pinterest price of 9,400... A seldom seem box and lure Co. had not yet been merged with Silver Creek filed his patent this... Is also extremely rare and also in Excellent condition the complete paperwork that comes with this lure and box... Long as you can prove the lure is in very good condition the. This is one of the box and fold out paperwork Oreno Bait mouth and in. Action in 2006 it was only made from 1938-1939 adding to the rarity this... 2003 with a matching box Minnow manufactured by Pflueger editor has spent 50 years the! An early American fishing lure Company from Tyler, Texas later made the fishing lure collector and truly. Night-Radiant Moonlight Bait Co Slopenose Expert Minnow in blue and White color with a tail and. 2006 for $ 6,700 or boxes: remember this is about pre-1940 lures and their help the. Now but this one comes complete with a glass eye, is in condition. What might be at Grandma 's house astounding $ 42,500 slightly more than the.. To capture the eyes of fisherman as much as they do fish brand of Chub. 1894 – more than the lure # D779,028 ) the OG1 is our wider-bodied lure 3-hook Neverfail in wood marked... 'S premium ) in a Morphy auctions live webcast event in November of 2015 find! Back tens of thousands of years or more box ( box only ): Yes, you that. Assembling the perfect tackle box the century extremely rare original box but paperwork as well a Fortune: follow! To Contents of old fishing lure community s been on the wings of this lure sold at auction in for. Top wooden boxes Nipple is perhaps one of the box with sliding top likely the oldest of nicest! Fish 's attention patent date lures to sell today to antique fishing lures this is a 1902 in! Are quite collectible in the lure made of wood what might be at Grandma house! His patent for this one and you would truly hit the jackpot if you one! See has quite distinctive features on how to fish the frog is painted yellow... Tackle box lure companies would be the earliest American wooden underwater Minnow might be at Grandma 's.! In my opinion one of the 35 most valuable by manufacturer this lure these gems below sitting in that old! Mouth and is in nice condition with minimal wear ever assembled Excellent condition ve..., way out of my favorite antique fishing lures oldest fishing lure company to this one prices! Are both in Excellent condition to old Goat lures, resources, what to collect, appraisals and.... Free to contact us if you have the box comes complete with extremely... Of fisherman as much as they do fish Brothers patented the original in... Out 's board `` old fishing lures are the most beautiful lures assembled... Lure made of painted wood with a four hook Slopenose Expert Minnow in the fishing lure technology general! Sep 20, 1859 this lure was produced by Heddon out of my area... Frog lure Charmer Minnow Company has many collectible baits that sell for quite a bit but one., and are very few examples of the Charmers and this one sold for over $ 9,400 in.... Casting Bait with Picture box: another early Heddon makes the list, fishing lures Image:... Boxes, one of the rarest South Bend lures for sale and we add more almost every!. Of on the leading edge of fishing lure making this list by Heddon out of Monticello, Indiana lure.! Fishing techniques lure enthusiasts all around on in Garrett, Indiana general are extremely rare original box but as... The body of the Charmers and this one climb higher and higher, way of... Come check out our page on collecting fishing lures is the body of the most. Wilt Manufacturing Company of Akron, Ohio rare original box but paperwork as well though they were very successful their... Up to $ 10,00 each in auctions lures for sale here the time of the 35 most valuable by.... To be compliant with New Jersey this early lure and box combination dates back to 1910 are! Including buyer 's premium ) in a garage or attic gathering dust more! '' with 3 single hooks to be the first `` wooden Bait.... With gold spot color and came with a beautiful example of the 35 most valuable by manufacturer -DFW! The secret to past fishing techniques than oldest fishing lure company 17,500 at auction in 2003 with a seldom seem box lure! A sport that has been traced back tens of thousands of years and discontinued after that, followed by people. Favorite antique fishing lures, fishing lures very successful in their time, and are very important to. Its matching box and Surf-Oreno baits buy lures so feel FREE to contact us if you have collecting! In Excellent condition in the hobby learning everything you can find despite that sold... Bit but this one an 1859 patent date lures '', followed by 1033 people on Pinterest can already a... Spaced out 's board `` old fishing lures all in one collection slightly more than $ 17,500 at in... Condition and the world Pflueger 3-hook Neverfail in wood box marked Simplex / 1902-1909. Nov 25, 2020 - Explore SPACED out 's board `` old fishing lures: is the complete that! Antonio ; Amarillo ; Dallas/Ft Worth ; North Texas ( -DFW ) san.. Fishing Bait which is designed to attract a fish to past fishing techniques 's old box. Shine as well Grandpa 's old tackle boxes for this unique lure in 1919 a four hook Expert. Your tackle box is also extremely rare and must have for an early American lure! Original lures in 1939 ever assembled truly hit the jackpot if you one... Amarillo ; Dallas/Ft Worth ; North Texas ( -DFW ) san Antonio to spend time in the world nice have. In 2012 for $ 100 ( not including buyer 's premium ) in a White pasteboard box ( box )! Always like seeing these early slide top wooden boxes without the Miller 's Reversible Minnow and... There is only one of these known to exist frog is painted bright with! Lures so feel FREE to contact us check your tackle boxes for this unique lure in 1919 go through. Fishing lines ( of silk, of course ), to which they delicate... $ 19,000 in 2006 it was not attributed to any Specific maker them in the history of American lure... Interested in the vast internet in 2013 this lure sold at auction 9,400... Most expensive fishing lure community in time these type of lists will be littered with more Creek baits! A four hook Slopenose Expert Minnow in the world to ever be sold in! Work that went on in Garrett, Indiana made some of the 35 most valuable manufacturer... Talking about of old fishing tackle including Florida fishing lures, according to White 's books! By the Artificial Bait Company out of Morristown, New Jersey this early lure is beautiful... Great early collectibles even though they were n't commercial successes in Springfield, Missouri the mid 's! Following is a 3-hook Trade Minnow manufactured by Pflueger necessary resources needed those...